Both lipsticks are completely unused. • Shade 330: Brand new, never used. It has minor smudging on the cap and inside the packaging due to handling during transit/storage. This is common with fresh lipsticks and does not mean it has been used. • Shade 240: Also unused, may have been lightly swatched once. I bought both from Sephora about 6-7 months ago, planning to use them. However, I mostly wear nude shades, so they have remained in storage and are now being sold. The price is set lower because the outer packaging of is missing/misplaced. The lipsticks themselves are in excellent condition. Final price – non-negotiable. I’m clearing out my collection, so this is the lowest I can go. A beautiful Estee Lauder lipstick with a rich, vibrant shade, luxurious feel, and excellent long-wear. Perfect for any occasion.